Where it differs: Elysia Vanilla adds cedar and extra vanilla to the same orchid, jasmine, brown sugar and tonka, and owners find the patchouli and jasmine heavier but the wear longer, near nine hours.

Smells like Kayali Vanilla 28.
13 bottles the community rates close to Vanilla 28, 80 percent cheaper at the top, with the one thing each does differently. floral, sweet, amber, for women.
Scent overlap
Both bottles' accords, strongest at the top, facing each other. A bar joined through the middle is one they share.
Notes of Vanilla 28
What Kayali publishes. Black means Dua Fragrances Magic Of Vanilla shares the note.
Top
- Madagascan Vanilla Orchid
- Jasmine
Heart
- Tonka
Base
- Brown Sugar
- Amber Woods
- Musk
- Patchouli
Notes of Magic Of Vanilla
What Dua Fragrances publishes. Black means Vanilla 28 shares the note.
Top
- Vanilla Orchid
- Jasmine
Heart
- Vanilla Infusion
- Vanilla Surabsolute
- Tonka
Base
- Brown Sugar
- Musk
- Patchouli
- Amber
- Vanilla
The 5 worth trying, ranked
Similarity is the owners' vote plus the note overlap. Price is a typical US bottle price when the house publishes one. Bars are each match's own accords.

Where it differs: Magic of Vanilla stacks extra vanilla infusion and surabsolute on the orchid, jasmine, tonka and brown sugar and drops the amber woods, so it reads more purely vanilla and less woody.

Where it differs: Woody Vanilla opens on boozy davana instead of vanilla orchid and jasmine, keeps brown sugar and patchouli, and owners find it sweeter with a slight smokiness and longer staying power.
Where it differs: Starlight Vanilla is a powdery lavender, almond and tonka vanilla with an aromatic, incense-like lean, missing Kayali's orchid, jasmine and brown sugar, and owners disagree on whether it resembles Vanilla 28.
Where it differs: Eshal Vanilla swaps the patchouli and brown sugar of Vanilla 28 for rose and caramel, and owners find it smoother in the opening, slightly less sweet, stronger and longer lasting.
8 more bottles people compare with Vanilla 28
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Similarity figures come from owner ratings and published notes, never from a lab, and no bottle here is a copy of another. Brand names appear only to say what a scent is similar to.
Side by side, the way people actually decide
Two bottles, two prices, one honest sentence. Every match on the site has this card.
Read about Dua Fragrances Magic Of Vanilla




